Independent creation in copyright law: what is plagiarism?

27/06/2025

Plagiarism is a well-known phenomenon in the artistic world. In the music industry, lawsuits regularly arise in which artists are accused of copying other people’s melodies or lyrics. Often, it revolves around a few consecutive notes or a rhythmic pattern, and that can already be enough to justify claims worth millions.

Accusations of plagiarism are also not uncommon in the film world. Storylines, scenes, or even visual styles can be considered “too strongly inspired” by other creators. Screenwriters regularly complain that large production houses use their ideas without their permission.

It also happens in literature, such as plot structures, characters, or writing styles that closely resemble a previously copyrighted work.

Conditions for copyright protection

To invoke plagiarism, it is required that the plaintiff can prove that their work enjoys copyright protection and thus meets the protection conditions.

There are two cumulative conditions in copyright law:

  • Originality: the work must be an intellectual creation of the author. In other words, it is “a personalized approach” because the author, through the choices they make, can give their personal touch that grants their work originality.
  • Concrete form: the form of the work is defined in relation to its counterpart: the idea. The principle is that ideas are excluded from protection. Copyright does not protect an idea or concept, nor a style, fashion trend, or genre. Only concrete forms of expression are protected by copyright.

It is therefore not so easy to prove the copyright protection of your work in practice. Moreover, “independent creation” is a fundamental concept in copyright law. It means that a work can enjoy copyright protection, even if it is not new and coincidentally strongly resembles an existing work.

Case: TV series “Knokke Off”

It is in this context that, for example, the Flemish crime author Piet Baete filed a complaint in early 2025 about the similarity between his book “Verzwijg mij niet” and the well-known TV series “Knokke Off”.

The book was published in 2011, the series was broadcast in 2023. According to VRT, the first proposal for Knokke Off was already written in 2008 and the creators of the series never read the book. Possible similarities would therefore be purely coincidental.

To legally refute the originality of “Knokke Off”, the presumption of copying would have to be invoked.

For this, three cumulative conditions must be met:

  • The anteriority (i.e., the book) must precede the contested work in time;
  • Both works must show sufficient similarities;
  • The author of the contested work must reasonably have been able to know the anteriority.

In such a hypothesis, the opposing party has the opportunity to refute the presumption by proving that there is in fact no anteriority, that it gives a different overall impression, or that they could not reasonably have known this anteriority (which VRT also put forward in this case).

If the opposing party fails to refute the above presumption, it is established that the work is not original and there is therefore an infringement of the earlier copyright.

The notion of “independent creation” indeed underlines that originality and novelty are separate concepts in copyright law. A work does not need to be new to still be considered original.

What does this mean for your business?

When your employees or collaborators create works that can enjoy copyright protection (think of presentations, texts, software, etc.), it is important that the creation processes are well documented (using sketches, designs, timestamps, etc.).

This can later prove, in case of a copyright dispute, that your work was created independently.

Our PKF BOFIDI Legal lawyers are ready for you

For further questions about copyright, feel free to contact our PKF BOFIDI Legal team and we will be happy to assist you.

This article was written by: Lauranne Piotrowski, who specializes in intellectual property, ICT, data protection and privacy.


Meer weten over

Subscribe to our newsletter

Receive insights in your mailbox

Subscribe
Secret Link